A
couple of showings ago in the Moviehouse, we took a look back at the
controversy over who really directed “Poltergeist” in 1982. Tobe Hooper,
brought on board on the strength of his work on the original “The Texas Chainsaw Massacre”
and the miniseries “Salem’s Lot,” received the screen credit as director, but
it’s no secret that producer Steven Spielberg, who conceived the project in the
first place and co-wrote the screenplay, was a daily visitor on the set.
![]() |
| "Creative producer" Steven Spielberg "visits" James Karen and Craig T. Nelson on the set of "Poltergeist." |
Since
Spielberg was preparing to shoot “E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial,” he was
contractually prevented from directing another movie, but that didn’t prevent
him from influencing Hooper as, in his own words, a “creative producer.” “Tobe
was very much involved,” a studio supervisor recalled, “but Steven was the
creative force…his stamp is on the film.” “This film was his baby,”
“Poltergeist” costar JoBeth Williams said of Spielberg.
Just
whose baby a motion picture is has been a frequently asked question in the
Moviehouse, especially when the credited director is suspected of being a
shadow or a puppet of a more domineering presence on the set.
The
1949 thriller “The Third Man” has
often been thought of as being directed by Orson Welles, onetime Hollywood boy
wonder who, in 1941, directed and starred in “Citizen Kane,” deemed by many
critics and film buffs the greatest movie ever made.
“The
Third Man” was, in fact, directed by Carol Reed, a British filmmaker who later
won an Academy Award for directing “Oliver!” Much ado
about nothing and virtually plotless, “The Third Man” is set in post-World War
II Vienna, Austria, a black market hotbed precariously policed by an
international force representing the occupying American, British, French, and
Russian allies. The threadbare script (penned by the acclaimed novelist Graham
Greene) has something to do with an American author of cowboy pulp
summoned to Vienna by a childhood friend named Harry Lime, who turns out to be
a suspected criminal, presumed to have been killed in a car accident.
A textbook example of style over substance, “The Third Man” has somehow been long regarded as a classic of film noir. There is no denying Orson Welles’ cinematic influence on the film: the wide-angle, deep-focus black-and-white photography, the off-kilter camera angles, the presence of Joseph Cotten (an original member of Welles’ storied Mercury Theatre company), and the surprise appearance, more than halfway into the picture, of Welles himself as Harry Lime.
One
internet reviewer observed that “it’s not really surprising to see
Welles-inspired shots in ‘The Third Man’…After all, isn’t ‘Citizen Kane’
supposed to be the film that inspired more people to become film directors than
any other movie? Therefore…any director having Welles acting in their film
would be prone to pay homage to Welles’ style of directing.”
One
contribution Orson Welles did make to “The Third Man” was Harry Lime’s “cuckoo
clock” speech, head-scratchingly inconsequential, with nothing to do with
anything else in the movie, but that hasn’t stopped it from being a fan
favorite. Lime tells his friend, “In Italy for thirty years under the Borgias
they had warfare, terror, murder and bloodshed, but they produced Michelangelo,
Leonardo da Vinci, and the Renaissance. In Switzerland they had brotherly love,
500 years of democracy and peace, and what did that produce? The cuckoo clock.”
In the 1992 book This Is Orson Welles,
co-written by Peter Bogdanovich, Welles admitted, “When the picture came out,
the Swiss very nicely pointed out to me that they’ve never made any cuckoo
clocks.” The cuckoo clock originated in Germany’s Black Forest region.
For
a film not directed by Orson Welles that nonetheless cast his
inimitable shadow, one need to only go back six years prior to “Third Man” for
a screening of “Journey Into Fear” (1943),
a spy thriller featuring Joseph Cotten as an American armaments engineer caught
up in wartime intrigue in Istanbul. Welles, who portrays the imposing colonel
of the Turkish secret police, produced the film and co-wrote the screenplay (with
Cotten) but never intended to direct it.
In
a contract he signed with RKO Pictures after “Citizen Kane,” Welles was allowed
to direct a considerable expensive production in which he would not act
(resulting in “The Magnificent Ambersons,” featuring Joseph Cotten) in exchange
for a bread-and-butter picture that he would not direct but in which he and his
stock company of Mercury Theatre actors could appear.
From
his days with the Mercury Theatre in New York City, Welles intended to nurture
directors, and for “Journey Into Fear,” he selected Norman Foster, a journeyman
filmmakers with a number of “Mr. Moto” and “Charlie Chan” cheapies to his
credit (pictured above). Foster never again came close to the stylistic look of “Journey Into Fear,”
subsequently finding his niche in 1950s and 1960s television. Turner Classic
Movies’ Paul Tatara noted, “Anyone who’s familiar with Welles’ expressionistic
shooting style will see his fingerprints all over ‘Journey Into Fear.’”
In
what could be called a directors’ hybrid, Norman Foster was nominally in charge
of “Journey Into Fear” while Welles would make improvements as he saw fit.
According to Paul Tatara, “One memorable sequence…on a building ledge in a
rainstorm, is almost certainly (Welles’) handiwork. Welles argued this away,
however, by saying that the actors and crew were all standing on a cramped,
dangerously high ledge, so the scene was directed by ‘whoever was nearest the
camera.’”
“Welles,”
Tatara observed, “had a propensity toward re-inventing his own past, so that
might explain his insistence that he was mostly a producer and screenwriter on
‘Journey Into Fear.’” Welles maintained, “My influence on ‘Journey Into Fear’
is so exaggerated.” He recalled when Norman Foster had him removed from the set
when he and costar Joseph Cotten couldn’t stop cracking up during a scene.
Welles
later said, “For the first five sequences, I was on the set and deciding
angles. From then on, I often said where to put the camera, described the
framings, made light tests.” In other words, “I designed the film but can’t
properly be called the director.”
RKO
promptly re-edited “Journey Into Fear” in Welles’ absence before releasing it
in the summer of 1942. Welles told Peter Bogdanovich that the film was “ruined
by the cutting. It was horrible what they did with what should have been a very
decent picture. Good cast and everything.”
![]() |
| "Journey Into Fear" reunited Orson Welles (far right) with his Mercury Theatre players and "Citizen Kane" costars Joseph Cotten and Everett Sloane. |
Welles
and Cotten wrote the screenplay as “the opposite of an action picture,” but the
studio “took out everything that made it interesting except the action, trying
desperately to turn it into an action” film, making, in the end, “quite a lot
of nothing about it.” Welles threatened to sue RKO but conceded to re-cutting
the last reel, shooting a new ending, and adding narration by Cotten. The
revised version, all 69 minutes of it, was released without fanfare in February
1943.
“’Journey
Into Fear’ may be a misfire,” TCM’s Paul Tatara remarked, “but it’s quite
unlike anything else that was released in 1942. And we have Orson Welles to
thank for that…even if he was loathe to admit it.”
By
all rights, Howard Hawks should have been given the screen credit for directing “The Thing from Another World,” a 1951
science-fiction scare fest about a bloodthirsty alien terrorizing a remote
Arctic scientific outpost. Based on John W. Campbell’s Who Goes There? – a verbose 1938 novella told mostly through
dialogue – the story was more faithfully adhered to, including its Antarctic
setting, in director John Carpenter’s 1982 remake “The Thing.” The 1951 film
played on the post-atom bomb skepticism about science meddling in matters best
left alone.
Howard
Hawks was a multi-talented filmmaker, equally adept at directing Humphrey
Bogart and Lauren Bacall in the film noir classics “To Have and Have Not” and
“The Big Sleep,” Cary Grant in such screwball comedies as “Bringing Up Baby,”
“His Girl Friday,” and “Monkey Business,” and John Wayne in the westerns “Red
River,” “Rio Bravo,” and “El Dorado.” In the 1950s, however, science fiction
wasn’t exactly a respected genre for a director of Hawks’ renown, so the story
goes that he hired Christian Nyby (an editor who worked with Hawks on “To Have
and Have Not,” “The Big Sleep,” and “Red River”) so the latter could receive
membership in the Directors Guild of America. RKO Pictures director’s salary
was $50,000. Hawks paid Nyby $5,460 and kept the rest, but Hawks always denied
directing the film.
George
Fenneman (best known as Groucho Marx’s sidekick on the comedy quiz show “You
Bet Your Life”), who played one of the Arctic scientists, recalled, “Hawks would
once in a while direct, if he had an idea, but it was Chris’ show.” Actor
Robert O. Cornthwaite said that “Chris always deferred to Hawks…Maybe because
he did defer to him, people misinterpreted it.” Costar William Self maintained,
“Hawks was directing the picture from the sidelines…Chris would stage each
scene, how to play it. But then he would go over to Howard and ask him for
advice, which the actors did not hear…Even though I was there every day, I
don’t think any of us can answer the question. Only Chris and Howard can answer
the question.”
At
a reunion of “The Thing from Another World” cast and crew members in 1982,
Christian Nyby said, “Did Hawks direct it? That’s one of the most inane and
ridiculous questions I’ve ever heard, and people keep asking. That it was
Hawks’ style. Of course it was. This is a man I studied and wanted to be like.
You would certainly emulate and copy the master you’re sitting under, which I
did. Anyway, if you’re taking painting lessons from Rembrandt, you don’t take the
brush out of the master’s hands.” Incidentally, after “The Thing from Another
World,” Nyby’s output as a director amounted to several episodes of numerous TV
series.
![]() |
| James Arness (pictured above as the titular "Thing from Another World") said that while Hawks spent a lot of time on the set, it was Nyby who actually directed the film. |
William
Self summed up, “Chris was the director in our eyes, but Howard was the boss in
our eyes.”
Speaking
of bosses, actor David Janssen once said, “Nobody runs roughshod over John
Wayne.” If there was one person who could run roughshod over John Wayne, it was
John Ford. The only director the actor allowed himself to be pushed around by,
Ford transformed the Duke from the hero of routine matinee westerns into a bona
fide movie star. Ford directed Wayne in 24 motion pictures and a handful of
television programs, so it only seemed natural that when Wayne decided to take the
giant step and direct his first big-budget movie, 1960’s “The Alamo,” his old mentor would visit the production.
Inspired
by the legendary defense of the Alamo Mission in what would become San Antonio by
260 or so “Texians” against a 13-day siege by a force of 1,800 Mexican troops,
the epic saga (which involved the construction of an authentic, three
quarter-scale replica of the Alamo in Bracketville, Texas, 125 miles west of
San Antonio) would feature Wayne as Tennessee frontiersman Davy Crockett, movie
tough guy Richard Widmark as folk hero Jim Bowie, and Laurence Harvey (best
known as “poor friendless, friendless Raymond” in the original “The Manchurian
Candidate”) as Col. William Travis.
According
to several of those involved with the film, John Wayne was an intelligent and
talented director, despite a weakness for screenwriter James Edward Grant’s
long-winded, patriotic dialogue. Even on the screen, Col. Travis grows weary of
Davy’s rambling “speechifyin’,” admonishing, “Please, Crockett, no homespun
wisdom, no cracker-barrel philosophy, none of your backwoods wit for which you
are famous.”
Randy
Roberts and James S. Olson, authors of A
Line in the Sand: The Alamo in Blood and Memory, described Wayne’s
directing as “competent but not outstanding.” Richard Widmark carped that Wayne
tried to tell him how to play his part which often went against his
interpretation of the character. Wayne would refer to Widmark as “Dick” until
the latter icily said, “It’s Richard.” Wayne went on to sarcastically emphasize
the name: “Are you ready for the next take, Richard?” Costar Ken Curtis
(a member of John Ford’s stock company of players who also happened to be
Ford’s son-in-law) remarked that Wayne had no ability to motivate an actor for
a scene.
![]() |
| When the student is ready the teacher will appear: John Wayne demonstrates to his mentor, John Ford, how to aim a musket on the set of "The Alamo." (Not pictured: Ol' Betsy) |
John
Ford arrived uninvited on the set of “The Alamo” and attempted to exert unasked
for influence on the production. John Wayne felt sorry for the old director
nicknamed “Pappy” and sent him off to film second-unit photography of the
Mexican cavalry riding through the countryside as they approached the Alamo.
Virtually none of Ford’s footage was used. It was re-filmed by a second unit
director, but Wayne didn’t have the heart to tell Ford. Nevertheless, John Ford
has often been erroneously described as an uncredited co-director of “The
Alamo.”
Eight
years later, John Wayne did share the directing credit for his second time behind the camera, on “The Green Berets,” an overblown, anti-communist, flag-waving paean
to U.S. Army Special Forces in the Vietnam War. In John Wayne: The Man Behind the Myth, author Michael Munn noted,
“There’s one particularly curious thing about the film’s behind-the-scenes
personnel. The credits say that the film was directed by John Wayne and Ray
Kellogg.” When the writer asked Jim Hutton (the comic relief in the
film as a light-fingered Army specialist) who Ray Kellogg was, the actor
replied, “Ah, the director of great classics such as ‘The Killer Shrews’ and
‘The Giant Gila Monster.’ What rare additions to the art of motion picture making
they are.”
Whenever
Munn asked other cast and crew members what Kellogg’s contribution to the movie
was, the response was, “Who’s Ray Kellogg?” Munn wrote, “Nobody has been able
to convince me so far that Ray Kellogg actually had any hand in the making of
‘The Green Berets.’” Nonetheless, John Wayne commented, “What can I say about
Ray Kellogg and ‘The Green Berets’? Without him, my career would not be what it
is today.”
As
a matter of fact, Warner Bros. dispatched a third director to work on “The Green
Berets,” which, according to Jim Hutton, “caused problems for Duke.” The new
director was Mervyn LeRoy, who had directed John Wayne in the 1946 romantic
comedy “Without Reservations.” (In 1955, LeRoy was brought on board to finish
“Mister Roberts” when original director John Ford was fired after butting heads
with stars Henry Fonda and James Cagney.) Even though LeRoy was retired, studio
head Jack Warner told him, “We’ve got six million dollars riding on this
picture, and I don’t think Wayne is coping well.”
David
Janssen, who portrayed a skeptical newspaper reporter accompanying the Special
Forces, recalled, “Duke tried to forget he had another director there and he’d
get on with giving the orders…Mervyn LeRoy would walk over and make some
suggestion…and Duke would nod his head, but I could see he wasn’t paying any
attention, and then Duke would get the scene the way he wanted it. I
think Mervyn LeRoy just went through the motions to keep Warner happy…he didn’t
want his name on the credits.”
![]() |
| Mervyn LeRoy (on the ground) checks out the camera angle while John Wayne oversees the action on the set of "The Green Berets." |
At
the end of what LeRoy described as “a very tough production for both of us,” he
told Wayne, “Take my advice. Forget directing and give your fans what they want
– John Wayne on the screen beating the shit out of the bad guy.” And that’s
just what Duke did the next year in “True Grit,” garnering the sole acting
Oscar of his career.
The
closest Steve McQueen came to a Best Actor Academy Award was a nomination for
his intense performance as a U.S. Navy machinist’s mate aboard a gunboat in
1920s China in “The Sand Pebbles” (1966). Like Clint Eastwood on the ‘60s
western series “Rawhide,” Steve McQueen embarked on the path to big-screen superstardom
as the star of a TV western, “Wanted: Dead or Alive” (1959-1961). And not
unlike Eastwood, McQueen warily paid close attention to what went on behind the
camera, hoping, as Clint did on “Rawhide,” for an opportunity to direct an
episode.
Flash-forward
nearly two decades: “Tom Horn” was
initially written by William Goldman, the Oscar-winning screenwriter of “Butch
Cassidy and the Sundance Kid” and “All the President’s Men,” for Robert
Redford, who would be directed by Don Siegel (“Dirty Harry”).
One
of the last of the Old West’s legendary gunfighters, the real-life Tom Horn (pictured below) was
a former cavalryman and scout, a fluent Indian interpreter and peerless tracker
during the Apache campaign who was among the handful of men who captured
Geronimo in 1886. Near the turn of the century, Horn became a “stock detective”
on behalf of ranchers in Wyoming, bringing harsh frontier justice to rustlers
with his crack marksmanship. In 1903, he was hanged for the shooting of a
rancher’s teenage son, a crime he most likely did not commit.
Robert
Redford dropped out of the “Tom Horn” project (more than likely opting instead
to star opposite Jane Fonda in “The Electric Horseman”), and when Steve McQueen
was signed to star, Don Siegel was replaced by director Elliott Silverstein
(best known for directing Richard Harris in “A Man Called Horse”). McQueen also
scrapped William Goldman’s script, which was promptly used for the two-part
made-for-television movie “Mr. Horn,” starring David Carradine, Richard
Widmark, and Karen Black, and broadcast prior to the theatrical release of “Tom
Horn.” (In his 2001 memoir Which Lie Did
I Tell? William Goldman admitted
he “couldn’t bring himself” to ever seeing “Mr. Horn,” writing, “This was one
of my bad experiences.”)
Director
Elliott Silverstein was replaced by James William Guercio, a music producer
noted for promoting Blood, Sweat & Tears and Chicago who dabbled in the
film industry as the producer-director of 1973’s “Electra Glide in Blue,” which
could be described as the flipside of “Easy Rider,” with Robert Blake as an
Arizona motorcycle cop. After three days of filming, Guercio was summarily
fired by McQueen, who, by this time, wanted to direct himself, but Directors
Guild of America regulations forbade actors from taking over directing once a
film had begun production. William Wiard, a journeyman television director, was
brought in to, at least for appearances sake, finish the film. A co-producer
recalled, “We started thinking it was going to be a $10 million epic, and it
ended up being a $3 million TV movie.”
During
the filming of “Tom Horn,” McQueen (pictured above) became aware of a persistent cough. After
the production wrapped, he learned he was dying of malignant mesothelioma. A
reviewer for the website dvdverdict.com observed, “The sight of a dying McQueen
playing the doomed Horn is both ironic and poignant.” The actor had earlier
told director of photography John Alonzo (a former actor who played a Mexican
peasant in “The Magnificent Seven,” Steve McQueen’s breakout movie) that it was
his destiny to tell the story of Horn. One wonders if he knew something was
very wrong with him and was fashioning the film into an epitaph for
himself.
![]() |
| Steve McQueen calls the shots on the set of "Tom Horn." |
There
is little question about who was really directing “Tom Horn” – Steve McQueen -
a man, in the words of Western Films
author Brian Garfield, “deaf and ill and hardly competent to direct a major
film.” The movie was a box office and critical disappointment. Garfield noted,
“It was largely (McQueen’s) meddling that caused the picture to be such a
botch.”
In
her 1986 memoir My Husband, My Friend,
McQueen’s former wife, Neile Toffel, wrote, “Steve’s biggest problem was his
inability to trust someone else’s judgment. He’d relegate responsibility and
then he would take it away.” When he worked with strong directors, the likes of
John Sturges (“The Magnificent Seven,” “The Great Escape”), Robert Wise (“The
Sand Pebbles”), and Peter Yates (“Bulitt”), Neile said “his contributions to
the success of his movies could be enormous.” When he was left to fend for
himself, “charged with making all the final decisions,” Neile pointed out, “his
360s were in great part to blame for his failures.”
“’Tom
Horn’ suffered from too many writers and too many directors,” Neile summed up.
“Steve was a stickler for details in all his movies. Unfortunately, he carried
it to such an extreme” that the film “suffered under the weight of all that
detail.”
On
the other hand, James Coburn, who costarred with Steve McQueen in three films
(“The Magnificent Seven,” “Hell Is for Heroes,” “The Great Escape”), as well as
in three episodes of “Wanted: Dead or Alive,” noted, “I thought ‘Tom Horn’ was
McQueen’s best film. He was loose and free…I always felt that Steve would
really be a good actor if he ever grew up…I think he finally did on ‘Tom Horn.’
That was him finding his adulthood.”
After
Clint Eastwood fired director Philip Kaufman and took over directing “The Outlaw
Josey Wales” himself - in Eastwood’s words, he “didn’t want it to be done the
way (Kaufman) was going to interpret it, and (Kaufman) didn’t want to do it the way I
wanted to do it” – the Directors Guild of America instituted a rule, which
became known as the “Eastwood Rule,” forbidding the replacement of a guild
member engaged for a film by anyone working in any capacity on the same
picture.
Presumably,
this was the rule that prevented Steve McQueen from officially taking over as
the director of “Tom Horn,” and in 1983, the rule would prevent Clint Eastwood
from formally replacing first-time director Richard Tuggle during the filming
of “Tightrope.” The film, not unlike
“The Gauntlet” a few years earlier (which found Clint playing a
down-and-on-his-way-out alcoholic cop), cast Eastwood as a tarnished detective,
a divorced father of two daughters with a dark obsession for kinky diversions,
tracking down a serial killer with a penchant for sex club prostitutes.
![]() |
| Detective Wes Block (Clint Eastwood) flirts with rape prevention advocate Beryl Thibodeaux (Genevieve Bujold) in "Tightrope." |
Richard
Tuggle, a film buff and Florida native living in San Francisco had been working
as an editor of a professional health magazine while entertaining ambitions to
become a screenwriter. “ Escape from Alcatraz” was the first screenplay he
attempted. It was filmed in 1979 by director Don Siegel, starring Clint
Eastwood. Tuggle, who scripted
“Tightrope,” purportedly came to the production uncertain of what he wanted and
equally unprepared for the technical demands of filmmaking, both of which were
cardinal sins in the eyes of the ever-efficient Eastwood.
As
noted by author Richard Schickel, in Clint
Eastwood, “A compromise was worked out. The writer would stay on,
contribute what he could in a collaboration and receive directorial credit,
while (Eastwood), literally, called most of the shots.”
Tuggle,
who viewed Eastwood as “a very complex person who had many different facets,”
understood that he was an untried director serving under Eastwood’s good will,
and that “his clout far out-equaled mine.” Tuggle admitted, “The politics on
the set made me uneasy, but artistically, I liked working with Clint. He was
smart, accessible and open to ideas.” According to Tuggle, “Some scenes were
done kind of by me. Some scenes were done kind of by him, and most of them were
done together…We’d have ideas together, but it was his crew and they would
basically be listening more to him, than to me.”
Tuggle
recalled, “This movie was walking a tightrope of its own. It’s trying to appeal
to a wide commercial Clint audience, and at the same time do something
different and take chances.”
Richard
Tuggle, incidentally, would direct only one other feature, “Out of Bounds,” a
1986 action thriller featuring former Brat Packer and original Rusty Griswold
from “National Lampoon’s Vacation” Anthony Michael Hall as an Iowa farm boy
mixed up with a drug kingpin in Los Angeles. In 1990, Tuggle co-wrote the
teleplay for an episode of the HBO series “Tales from the Crypt” (directed by,
of all people, Arnold Schwarzenegger) before dropping off the show business
radar.
After
hinting that his role in 2008’s “Gran Torino” would be his last performance in
front of the camera, Clint Eastwood surprised fans by returning to acting four
years later in the modest drama “Trouble with the Curve,” portraying a grizzled
Major League Baseball scout who attempts to reconnect with his estranged
daughter, played by Amy Adams.
The
film was also notable for the fact that Eastwood didn’t direct it – the first
time he let someone else direct him since 1993’s “In the Line of Fire,” which
was directed by Wolfgang Petersen (“Troy”). The task fell to Eastwood’s
longtime producing partner Robert Lorenz, making his debut as a director. (Most recently, Lorenz co-produced "Jersey Boys" and "American Sniper" with Eastwood.)
Unlike
Richard Tuggle’s experience with Eastwood on “Tightrope,” Lorenz told the
Chicago Tribune, “I want to set myself apart and set up my own style. He’s let
other people in his organization direct before and some had their own vision.
In other cases it felt like, we’ll just let someone else drive for a while. I
didn’t want to be locked into that category. And there was also the concern that
he might want to – or insist on – imposing his own style.”
Lorenz
commented in the Chicago Tribune interview, “Clint is very much his own man,
his own artist…We don’t agree on everything. We don’t agree entirely on film
styles or politics…But we both love moviemaking, that’s where we bond. I knew
exactly how I wanted to shoot this. If I had shown any uncertainty, he might
have felt compelled to step in…There were a couple moments where he had an idea
and I had a different idea and everybody was sort of looking back and forth at
us. But we worked it out. We did it my way.”
![]() |
| Robert Lorenz directs Clint Eastwood his way in "Trouble with the Curve." |

























1 comment:
I would watch "The Third Man" a lot more often if it wasn't for that darned zither music!
Post a Comment