Introduction: The Eyes Have It
In William Shakespeare's time, it was commonly believed there were five "wits." These five outward wits continue to be regarded as our modern concept of the five senses: sight, hearing, smell, taste, and touch. Depictions of the five senses as an allegory became a very popular subject for 17th century painters, including Dutch artist Gerard de Lairesse, whose 1668 work "Allegory of the Five Senses" is pictured here.
Sight develops gradually over the first six months of life, and by about seven months, a newborn's eyesight is mature, followed by improvements in depth perception and eye-hand coordination.
A common question people pose to one another is, "Which would you rather lose, your sight or your hearing?" Overwhelmingly, most would sacrifice their ability to hear over the gift of sight. In a November 2015 online survey, 5000 people were asked, "Which sense would you give up?" By a sizable margin, 56% said smell, followed by 21% taste, 13% touch, 6% hearing, and, not surprisingly, 4% said sight.
A question we ponder in the Moviehouse is which sense would you give up half of? Which is a sneaky way to segue into an overlooked (pardon the pun) aspect of cinema, both in front of and behind the camera: the world of the single-sighted.
Chapter I: One-Eyed Ogres
"In the country of the blind, the one-eyed man is king" is an adage attributed to Erasmus of Rotterdam, a Dutch Renaissance priest-humanist-social critic. It was used by H.G. Wells in his 1904 short story "The Country of the Blind," about a mountaineer in Ecuador who descends into a secluded valley inhabited solely by blind villagers who live in windowless homes and navigate streets lined with high curbs, having subsisted for several sightless generations cut off from the rest of the world. The enterprising mountain climber sees an opportunity to rule over the community, but the villagers, who have no concept of sight, don't understand his explanation of the fifth sense. Ultimately, the townspeople propose the removal of the stranger's eyes since they are diseased and affecting his brain, prompting the mountaineer to high-tail it back into the hills, without equipment or provisions but with his sight intact, hoping to find a way back to the outside world.
We'd like to take you back to the time of the ancient Greeks, whose myths - that is to say their religion - frequently contained references to eyes, from any of a number of eyes to the loss of eyesight completely. Argus was a primordial giant with 100 eyes who served as a guardsman in the service of the queen of the gods, Hera.
In one of his many extramarital pursuits, Hera's husband and head honcho on Mount Olympus, Zeus, dispatched Hermes, the messenger of the gods, to dispatch Argus. Hermes cast magic spells that closed the giant's eyes one by one, then slew him with a well-placed rock to the cranium. In honor of her faithful watchman, Hera preserved Argus' eyes forever in the tails of peacocks.
The Graeae, or "grey witches," were three blind sister-seeresses who passed a single eye between themselves. The Greek hero Perseus snatched the eye to coerce the witches to help him on his quest to slay Medusa. Oedipus, the legendary king of Thebes, stabbed out his own eyes with a pair of brooches when he learned that he had unwittingly killed his father and married his mother. The myth of Oedipus also included the presence of Tiresias, a prophet of Apollo who happened to be blind.
In the early myths of ancient Greece, the cyclopes, a race of giants each with a single eye in the center of the forehead, were blacksmiths who aided the god Hephaestus, the ironworker of Olympus (pictured above). They forged Zeus' lightning bolts, Hades' helmet of invisibility and Poseidon's trident. Some sources say the legend of the cyclopes stemmed from the practice of blacksmiths wearing a single eye patch to prevent flying sparks from blinding them in both eyes.
As depicted by Homer in the "Odyssey," Polyphemus (pictured above) and his kith and kin were of a different lineage, developing an appetite for human flesh. Trapped in Polyphemus' cave and intended to be devoured, Odysseus tricked the giant into getting drunk on undiluted wine. (The wily Odysseus was the brains behind the Trojan horse that led the way to the sack of Troy.) When the cyclops passed out, Odysseus drove a fire-hardened wooden stick into his eye.
In the 1954 production of "Ulysses," starring Kirk Douglas, Polyphemus was portrayed by Umberto Silvestri (pictured above), an Olympic Greco-Roman wrestler who appeared in several Italian sword-and-sandal epics in the 1950s and '60s.
Nearly six decades later, another burly athlete, former British rugby lock forward Martin Bayfield (pictured below), played the Cyclops Elder in 2012's "Wrath of the Titans," a mash-up of Greek myths tossed together in a slapdash sequel to 2010's "Clash of the Titans," which itself was a remake of the 1981 picture starring Harry Hamlin as Perseus and Laurence Olivier as Zeus. Sam Worthington and Liam Neeson portrayed Perseus and Zeus in the reboots.
By the way, "O Brother, Where Art Thou?" (2000), the loopy, picaresque road movie directed by siblings Joel and Ethan Coen, was, so they tell us, inspired by Homer's "Odyssey," illustrated by the name of George Clooney's character, Ulysses Everett McGill; the appearance of seductively singing sirens; and, among other allusions, John Goodman's cyclopean role as an ogrish, one-eyed Bible salesman (pictured below).
That trash compactor of direct-to-video refuse called the SyFy Channel presented a sympathetic (yet sloppily computer-animated) portrait of the mythical cyclops in the same-titled 2008 movie, featuring an over-the-top performance by Eric Roberts as the evil Emperor Tiberius (the real-life great-grand uncle of Nero).
That trash compactor of direct-to-video refuse called the SyFy Channel presented a sympathetic (yet sloppily computer-animated) portrait of the mythical cyclops in the same-titled 2008 movie, featuring an over-the-top performance by Eric Roberts as the evil Emperor Tiberius (the real-life great-grand uncle of Nero).
![]() |
| Apparently, a diaper-clad cyclops pursues Little Red Riding Hood in 2008's "Cyclops," which was filmed, as so many other SyFy Channel fodder are, in Bulgaria. |
Eric Roberts, the older brother of Julia Roberts (the two were estranged until a 2004 reconciliation), was once nominated for a Best Supporting Actor Oscar, for his role in 1985's "Runaway Train," with Jon Voight and Rebecca De Mornay. He had legitimate roles in "The Dark Knight" and "The Expendables" while becoming a familiar face in countless, cheesy direct-to-video fodder, including his hammy performance as a mad scientist in the SyFy Channel's"Sharktopus," which, like "Cyclops," was produced by Roger Corman and his wife, Julie.
Leave it to The Three Stooges (the trio with Joe DeRita) to encounter conjoined cyclopes when they travel back in time to mythical Greece in 1959's "The Three Stooges Meet Hercules" (pictured below). The monster was played by twin brothers Merlin McKeever and Mike McKeever. Merlin enjoyed a 13-year career in the NFL, while Mike's football future was cut short by a head injury in his senior year at USC.
![]() |
| The Stooges overpower the Cyclopes with the help of Curly Joe's sleeping pills in "The Three Stooges Meet Hercules." |
Emerging from the mists of ancient myths and legends, we find ourselves in the Atomic Age, when unchecked radiation created gigantic, mutant insects, animals, and humans, not to mention awakening a long-dormant albeit fictitious dinosaur called Godzilla (or Gojira, if you're picky). Writer-producer-director Bert I. Gordon established himself as the grade Z-movie auteur of giant human and monster pictures, including "The Amazing Colossal Man," "War of the Colossal Beast," "Village of the Giants," and "Empire of the Ants." Gordon's 1957 opus, "The Cyclops" (pictured below) presented a mutated, 25-foot human monstrosity, yet one more cinematic victim of exposure to radioactivity. The supporting cast included B-movie stalwart Lon Chaney Jr.
Speaking of animated cyclopes, we would be remiss for not mentioning Mike Wazowski, the diminutive, green-skinned station runner and coach at the Monsters, Inc. factory in the 2001film of the same name. Voiced by Billy Crystal, Mike returned in the 2013 prequel, "Monsters University," and popped up in "Cars." The character (pictured below, with Boo, in "Monsters, Inc.") appeared in wordless cameos in "Finding Nemo" and "WALL-E."
Chapter II: Short-Sighted Scalawags, Seafarers and a Senora
It's time to orient ourselves to the real world, where we find the cinema's favorite, and most influential, single-eyed character - the eyepatch-wearing pirate. Remember the image of the pirate in those old "Draw Me!" ads for Art Instruction Schools that appeared in comic books and magazines?
Among the instructors at the Art Instruction Schools, headquartered in Minneapolis, Minnesota, were Mort Walker, creator of "Beetle Bailey," and "Peanuts" creator Charles Schulz, who had attended the school in his teens during the Depression.
With a great degree of trepidation (to be explained subsequently), we ask, "Why would pirates wear eyepatches?" Was it to cover the loss of an eye in a sea battle or ship raid? Jim Sheedy, a doctor of vision science and director of the Vision Performance Institute as Oregon's Pacific University, posited an alternative explanation. In 2013, he told the Wall Street Journal that the "smart" pirates "wore a patch over one eye to keep it dark-adapted outside." When the buccaneer went below decks, he moved the patch to his outdoor eye to easily see in the darkness.
According to Sheedy, the eyes can take up to 25 minutes to adapt from dazzling daylight to near darkness, a process that requires the regeneration of photo pigments. By his fanciful theory, a swashbuckler would simply switch the eyepatch and immediately be ready to buckle his swash in the lower decks without stumbling over barrels of rum or running into walls.
In fact, military survival guidelines for nighttime maneuvers recommend soldiers keep one eye closed or covered when encountering bright lights to preserve night vision in the protected eye. The same goes for military pilots.
In a special pirate-themed episode in 2007, Discovery Channel's "MythBusters" tested the eyepatch hypothesis and determined that it was indeed plausible. However - and this is the cause for the aforementioned trepidation - there are no first-hand accounts of pirates wearing eyepatches. In the 2016 book The Golden Age of Piracy: The Truth Behind Pirate Myths, author Berenson Little, who insisted there is "zero evidence" for the vision theory, noted, "In reality, the eyepatch was never specifically associated with pirates except in fiction and films."
Robert Louis Stevenson's classic tale of a pirate called Long John Silver and buried booty, Treasure Island, was originally serialized in a children's magazine from 1881 to 1882 and published as a book in 1883. Stevenson's fiction introduced a number of tropes associated with pirates - the peg leg, the cocked tricorn hat, the parrot perched upon a shoulder, the buried treasure - but not a single mention of an eyepatch. Nor can an eyepatch be found in any screen adaptation of the novel.
![]() |
| N.C. Wyeth's illustrations for Treasure Island in 1911 included this depiction of Long John Silver and Jim. |
![]() |
| ...But no eyepatch... |
![]() |
| N.C. Wyeth illustrated Treasure Island in 1911, the year that his mentor, Howard Pyle, died. |
![]() |
| Life magazine devoted a four-page photo-story to the 1967 opening of "Pirates of the Caribbean" in Anaheim's Disneyland. The attraction made its debut in Disney World's Magic Kingdom six years later. |
In 1972, Hammer Film Productions cast Christopher Lee (who typically donned Dracula's black-and-red cape in several movies for the studio) as sadistic Captain LaRoche in the low-budget potboiler "The Pirates of Blood River" (pictured below).
![]() |
| Oliver Reed (as crewmate Brocaire) listens to Christopher Lee lead a privateer pep rally in "The Pirates of Blood River." |
![]() |
| Michael Wincott in the 1993 Disney-meets-"Young Guns" version, featuring Charlie Sheen and Kiefer Sutherland... |
![]() |
| and Mads Mikkelson in 2011's 3-D "The Three Musketeers," directed by Paul W.S. Anderson, the auteur behind the "Resident Evil" movies. |
The image of an eyepatch-wearing pirate might have been inspired by a noteworthy non-pirate. At the 1794 Siege of Calvi in Corsica during the French Revolutionary Wars, British Naval commander Horatio Nelson suffered a serious facial wound that cost him the use of his right eye. Three years later, his right arm was partially amputated after an encounter with a cannonball in an assault on a Spanish port city in the Canary Islands. Legend has it that a half hour after the battlefront surgery, Nelson was back on his feet, issuing orders to his crew.
Nelson's heroics turned him into a living legend, and to draw attention to Nelson's wartime exploits, artists often depicted him with an eyepatch (something he probably never really wore), as pictured above in the porcelain figurine. Over time, the public may have associated eyepatches with swashbuckling adventures at sea.
In the 19th century, George Cruikshank, a British caricaturist best known for illustrating a number of books by his contemporary, Charles Dickens, provided illustrations for an anthology whimsically titled The Universal Songster; or Museum of Mirth: forming the Most Complete, Extensive and Valuable Collection of Ancient and Modern Songs in the English Language, which included "The Old Commodore," a ditty about an aging seaman afflicted with gout who doesn't want to die on land. Note, as depicted below, that Cruikshank gave the "tough old commodore" an eyepatch.
More than likely, in our modest opinion, the stereotypical image of a buccaneer in an eyepatch may have been inspired by a series of magazine ads for a line of men's clothing featuring the "Hathaway Man" (pictured below) . C.F. Hathaway Company was a private manufacturer of men's shirts, founded in 1837. The company, which made uniform shirts for Union soldiers during the Civil War, became famous for its "man-with-the-eyepatch" ad campaign starting in the 1950s.
Chapter III: One-Eyed Jacks...and Jills
Regardless of the origin of filmdom's stylish facial accessory, the template was forged for cinema's suavest, most fashion-conscious bad guys and antiheroes. Where better to start this chapter of screen history than the 007 movies?
In Thunderball, the ninth published James Bond novel, Emilio Largo, the number two man in the international crime syndicate called SPECTRE (second only to Ernst Stavro Blofeld), was described by author Ian Fleming as an imposing, muscular, olive-skinned Italian with long sideburns and hairy hands. As portrayed by Sicilian-born actor Aldofo Celi In the 1965 film "Thunderball" (the fourth 007 movie starring Sean Connery), Sicilian-born Adolfo Celi cut a more refined figure as Largo, complete with a stylish eyepatch not mentioned by Fleming.
![]() |
| Bond and Largo match wits over a table of 007's favorite card game of baccarat, under the watchful gaze of Largo's mistress, Domino (Claudine Auger), in "Thunderball." |
In 1957, B-movie action star (and noted furniture craftsman) George Montgomery starred as a New Mexico town marshal who lost an eye during the Civil War in the low-budget horse opera "Black Patch." The New York Times offered, "There have been far worse little westerns."
![]() |
| In a ludicrously posed publicity shot for "Black Patch," George Montgomery takes a punch from tough-guy costar Leo V. Gordon, who also wrote the terse script. |
![]() |
| Now you don't see it, now you do...Throughout most of the action in "The Vikings," Kirk Douglas opts for the carefree, patch-less look. |
![]() |
| An illuminated 11th-century manuscript offered this depiction of the one-eyed Odin. |
The ad worked, as her career saw new life throughout the 1960s, albeit in a series of outre performances in often macabre thrillers. In "What Ever Happened to Baby Jane?" she played an aging former child star who torments her paraplegic sister (Joan Crawford); in "Dead Ringer," she essayed a dual role as estranged twins, one of whom murders the other to assume her identity; in "The Nanny," she was cast as a Mary Poppins-from-hell; and in the title role in "Hush...Hush, Sweet Charlotte," she portrayed an eccentric recluse suspected of decapitating her lover (Bruce Dern) decades earlier.
In 1968's "The Anniversary," written and directed by veteran filmmakers from Hammer Film Productions, a studio noted for its bloody revival of Dracula, Frankenstein, and Mummy pictures in the 1950s and '60s, featured Bette Davis as a cruel, manipulative matriarch of a dysfunctional family (pictured below). The New York Times called it "a horror film for faint-hearted horror movie fans."
![]() |
| (Middle) Between John Wayne and Jeff Bridges, Warren Oates had the unenviable task of essaying the role of Rooster Cogburn in the 1978 TV movie "True Grit: A Further Adventure." |
On the Axis side of the European Theater in the war, Robert Duvall portrayed a fictional one-eyed German colonel (pictured below) who plots to kidnap British Prime Minister Winston Churchill and spirit him into Germany in 1976's "The Eagle Has Landed," a rousing, slam-bang adventure costarring Michael Caine, Donald Sutherland, Jenny Agutter, Donald Pleasence (as Himmler), Anthony Quayle, Treat Williams, and Larry Hagman. It was the last movie directed by John Sturges, a no-nonsense filmmaker best known for such classic guy movies as ""Gunfight at the O.K. Corral," "The Magnificent Seven," and "The Great Escape."
There was a real-life one-eyed German colonel, who spearheaded a conspiracy to assassinate Adolf Hitler near the end of World War II. Claus Philipp Maria Schenk Graf von Stauffenberg was also a count (Hitler hated the German nobility) who was wounded severely during the 1942 Tunisia Campaign in North Africa, losing his left eye, his right hand, and two fingers on his left hand. He jokingly told friends he never knew what to do with so many fingers when he had them.
![]() |
| Claus von Stauffenberg before the wounds. |
After a shootout with German troops that left him wounded in his shoulder, Stauffenberg was captured and later executed by a firing squad. He initially received a burial with military honors, but within a day, the SS exhumed his body, stripped his uniform of medals, and cremated his remains. Stauffenberg's widow and five children successfully fled the country; his wife died in 2006 at age 92. Not so lucky was the count's older brother, who, along with seven other conspirators, was executed by slow strangulation with piano wire. Over 20,000 Germans were eventually killed or dispatched to concentration camps in the ensuing purge. As for Adolf, just over nine months following the assassination attempt, the pathetic little art school reject shot himself in the head in a bomb shelter under a ruined garden near the Reich Chancellery in Berlin.
Actor Wolfgang Preiss (who played a German general in the epic World War II movie "The Longest Day") garnered a German Federal Film Award for his role as Claus von Stauffenberg in the 1955 German picture "The Plot to Assassinate Hitler" (pictured below).
![]() |
| Wolfgang Preiss may have won an award for his 1955 portrayal of Claus von Stauffenberg, but he had the patch on the wrong eye. |
When Tom Cruise was cast as Stauffenberg in 2008's "Valkyrie" ("Operation Valkyrie" became the name of the plot to oust Nazi leadership), German politicians were reluctant to allow the filmmakers to utilize historical locations due to the actor's belief in Scientology, which is regarded suspiciously in the country. Cruise (pictured below), at first, found the character's eyepatch difficult to work with, but the diminutive thespian toughed it out, acknowledging that the real Stauffenberg had to live with the discomfort.
For the role of antihero Snake Plissken in filmmaker John Carpenter's dystopian fantasy "Escape from New York" (1981), Kurt Russell (pictured below) himself suggested the signature eyepatch. The character, a hero of the so-called "Leningrad Campaign," was described by the A.V. Club's Keith Phipps as "a cross between Clint Eastwood and a damaged Vietnam vet." Russell, who was eager to shed his lightweight screen image from a number of Disney comedies (like "The Computer Wore Tennis Shoes"), could still fit into the original costume 15 years later when he reprised Snake in the long overdue 1996 sequel, "Escape from L.A."
For a low-budget director, Mark L. Lester has consistently displayed a flair for action and a talent for blowing things up, in a diverse filmography that includes "Truck Stop Women" (starring 1970 Playmate of the Year Claudia Jennings), "Bobbie Jo and the Outlaw" (featuring the screen debut of TV's "Wonder Woman," Lynda Carter), "Roller Boogie" (OK, nothing blows up here, but there is the sight of star Linda Blair trying to bust out of her roller rink outfit)...
..."Class of 1984" (a cult thriller that gave Michael J. Fox an early film role), "Commando" (an over-the-top Schwarzenegger action flick with Arnold alone responsible for a body count of 81), and "Armed and Dangerous" (an action comedy misfire with John Candy, Eugene Levy, and Meg Ryan).
In 1984, Mark L. Lester joined the long list of moviemakers to adapt Stephen King's tales to the screen with "Firestarter," starring Drew Barrymore as a "pyrokinetic" whiz kid who can spark blazes with her mind. (King coined the term "pyrokinesis" in his 1980 novel.) Portraying sinister government agents are Martin Sheen and George C. Scott, the latter particularly creepy as assassin John Rainbird, a ponytailed Native American who was badly scarred in the Vietnam War (pictured below). His befriending of the nine-year-old Barrymore's character, whom he intends to kill to assimilate her power, borders uncomfortably on pedophilia (Roger Ebert's review bluntly referred to his role as a "child molester").
Rainbird somehow survived the climactic conflagration in the original film to return as a menace in a 2002 made-for-television sequel "Firestarter 2: Rekindled," a two-part "miniseries" that premiered on the SyFy Channel. Malcolm McDowell played the even more badly scarred hitman, John Rainbird, sans the eye covering, in a cast that included Dennis Hopper (pictured below).
Coincidentally, Everett McGill played the husband of a woman in an eyepatch on TV's "Twin Peaks." Five years after "Silver Bullet," Everett McGill, who had played Stilgar in director David Lynch's 1984 version of "Dune," was cast in the Mark Frost-David Lynch series as gas station owner Big Ed Hurley, suffering a dysfunctional marriage to Nadine Hurley (played by Wendy Robie), an extraordinarily strong woman obsessed with creating silent drape-runners who lost an eye in a hunting accident on her honeymoon (pictured below). In 1991, McGill and Robie were reunited as creepy "Daddy" and "Mommy" in Wes Craven's "The People Under the Stairs."
Thirty years after gouging out his eyes as the Greek king who found out he killed his father and married his mother in "Oedipus the King," Christopher Plummer donned an eyepatch for his role as treacherous Klingon General Chang in 1991's "Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country." Plummer asked that his alien makeup be subtle to give the character a more human appearance. For whatever reason, Chang's eyepatch was mentioned as being bolted to his head.
![]() |
| Fond of quoting Shakespeare throughout "Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country," Chang's last words are, "To be, or not to be." |
As related in Rob Lowe's memoir, Stories I Only Tell My Friends, the young actor was leaving a charity dinner in the mid-1980s when he said good night to a table that included Cary Grant, Robert Wagner, and Prince Rainier of Monaco. As he walked away, Lowe overheard Wagner mutter, "Ya know, guys, I think that kid's banged each one of our daughters." Truth be told, in the '80s, Lowe dated Jennifer Grant (Cary's only child, from his three-year marriage to actress Dyan Cannon), Kate Wagner (daughter of Robert and his second wife, actress Marion Marshall), and Princess Stephanie of Monaco. Upon meeting Cary Grant for the first time, Rob Lowe received a piece of advice he would never forget. The elder actor intoned, "Young man, don't ever eat a hot dog on a dais...Because then there'll be a picture of you with a hot dog in your mouth!"
To prepare for his role, Lowe watched several reruns of Wagner's '80s series "Hart to Hart." In an interview with Larry King, Wagner beamed, "That's my boy, Rob Lowe!"
Daryl Hannah, an actress known for such reserved roles as a naive beauty school graduate in "Steel Magnolias" and as, literally, a fish-out-of-water in "Splash," was cast against type as Elle Driver, code-named California Mountain Snake, the cruelest member of the Deadly Viper Assassination Squad in Quentin Tarantino's epic revenge saga, "Kill Bill Vol. 1" and "Kill Bill Vol. 2." As an insolent student of Pai Mei, a venerable teacher of the Bak Mei and Eagle's Claw styles of kung fu, Elle had her right eye plucked out by the insulted master.
A California Institute of the Arts student, Kelly Conran had grown up fascinated by the unchecked imagination and fantastical whimsy of old-time pictures like "Metropolis," "King Kong" and "Lost Horizon" and of such vintage serials as "Flash Gordon." He became single-mindedly obsessed with creating his own adventure magnum opus in the same spirit of his childhood memories. Conran, with the help of his brother and friends, labored for years on an outdated Macintosh personal computer to craft a six-minute "teaser" that was enough to interest Jon Avnet, the director of "Fried Green Tomatoes" and executive producer of "Black Swan," to not only come on board as a producer of what would become "Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow" (2004) but also to present the idea to stars Gwyneth Paltrow and Jude Law.
"Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow" was the first major motion picture shot completely against a blue screen, with computer-generated sets, location backgrounds, and special effects added in post-production. Also added was footage of a young Laurence Olivier (who had been deceased 15 years before the movie's release), which was manipulated for his "role" as the story's mad scientist and supervillain. Conran's revolutionary approach would influence the filmmakers of "Sin City" and "300."
![]() |
| Before and after: Kelly Conran directs Jude Law and Gwyneth Paltrow on the bare-bones blue-screen set (top) prior to the magic of post-production computerized enhancement. |
In the fourth, fifth, and seventh films in the "Harry Potter" franchise, Gleeson loomed large as Professor Alastor "Mad-Eye" Moody (pictured below), famed for capturing several criminal wizards while losing various body parts in the process, including part of his left leg, a slice of his nose, and his left eye.
Back in 1998, David Hasselhoff (pictured below) starred in the title role of the TV movie "Nick Fury: Agent of Shield" (forgoing the acronym), a TV movie that benefitted from a comic-savvy teleplay by David S. Goyer, who has worked on the screenplays for the "Blade" trilogy, the "Dark Knight" trilogy, "Ghost Rider" and its sequel, "Man of Steel," and "Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice."
In 1994's "True Lies," the appearance and mannerisms of Spencer Trilby, the commander of the covert counter-terrorism task force called Omega Sector for which Arnold Schwarzenegger's Harry Tasker works, were inspired by the character Nick Fury as originally depicted in Marvel Comics. For the brief role of Trilby, director James Cameron wanted an actor who could "plausibly intimidate" Schwarzenegger. Enter Charlton Heston, who, in the twilight of his career, strapped on the eyepatch and impressively intimidated Arnold.
When he appeared in his cameo role for "True Lies," Charlton Heston was at a point in his career where he performed, more or less, walk-ons, in such films as "Wayne's World 2," "Tombstone," John Carpenter's "In the Mouth of Madness," Kenneth Branagh's "Hamlet," Oliver Stone's "Any Given Sunday," Tim Burton's "Planet of the Apes," even a cheesy Jean-Claude Van Damme action flick, "The Order"...just so filmmakers like Cameron, Carpenter, Branagh, Stone, Burton, and even Van Damme could say, "Hey, I worked with the great Charlton Heston!"
Before being terrorized by sadistic dictator Negan and his barbed wire-wrapped baseball bat dubbed "Lucille" on "The Walking Dead," former Sheriff's Deputy Rick Grimes (Andrew Lincoln) had to contend with - from 2012 to 2015 - The Governor, the sociopathic leader of an antagonistic militia who besieges Rick's community of survivors occupying a prison in Georgia. The Governor's right eye was poked out by a glass shard wielded by Michonne (Danai Gurira), whose usual weapon of choice is the Japanese sword called a katana.
![]() |
| The gruesome makeup for Carl's eye wound took nine hours to apply. |
Michelle Rodriguez (pictured above, with Danny Trejo), reprised her role as Luz in the disappointing 2013 sequel, "Machete Kills," appearing alongside other returning cast members Jessica Alba and Tom Savini, as well as newcomers Mel Gibson, Lady Gaga, Antonio Banderas, Cuba Gooding Jr., and Charlie Sheen, who was credited by his birth name, Carlos Estevez.
Speaking of Lady Gaga, the iconoclastic, multi-Grammy Award-winning singer-songwriter typified a trend among pop music divas by inexplicably voguing in fashionable designer eyepatches (pictured below).
...Rihanna, winner of eight Grammy Awards and 12 Billboard Music Awards, performed at the 2008 American Music Awards in an elegant eyepatch...
Barbados-born Rihanna reprised the look for a 2009 music video, then donned a chic, "see-through" eyepatch in the artwork for the release of the 2009 single "Russian Roulette" from her fourth studio album...
Far be it for the godmother of voguing to be be left out in the cold without an eyepatch...
Chapter IV: One Eye on the Action
Probably one of the most recognizable real-life figures who wore a trademark eyepatch was Moshe Dayan (pictured below), the Israeli minister of defense who became the hero of 1967's Six-Day War against the United Arab Republic. In the summer of 1941, early in World War II, English forces invaded Syria and Lebanon, which were occupied by the Nazi-puppet government of Vichy France. As a member of the British-organized Jewish Auxiliary Police, Dayan led a unit that captured a Vichy police station in southern Lebanon. He was scanning Vichy French positions from the building rooftop when a French sniper's bullet struck Dayan's binoculars, sending glass and metal fragments into his left eye. The extensive damage to his ocular muscles prevented Dayan's ability to use a glass eye.
Dayan grew to despise his signature patch, writing in his autobiography that he was "ready to make any effort and stand any suffering, if only I could get rid of my black eyepatch. The attention it drew was intolerable to me." In 2005, 24 years after Dayan's death from a massive heart attack, his eyepatch was offered for auction on eBay with a starting bid of $75,000.
But we digress. In the Moviehouse, we turn our attention to filmmakers with a singular - literally - vision. The prodigious career of legendary director Raoul Walsh spanned a half century, from the silent era to the 1960s and included such screen classics as "High Sierra" (starring Humphrey Bogart), "They Died with Their Boots On" (featuring Errol Flynn as George Armstrong Custer), "Desperate Journey" (teaming Flynn with Ronald Reagan), and "White Heat" (starring James Cagney). In his early years, Walsh also acted in silent pictures, including a role as assassin John Wilkes Booth in D.W. Griffith's "The Birth of a Nation."
It was Walsh who gave furniture-moving prop "boy" and bit player Marion Morrison his shot to Hollywood stardom in the 1930 western "The Big Trail" (pictured below). Walsh wanted to change the young man's screen name to Anthony Wayne, as he was enthralled at the time with a biography of American Revolutionary War hero General "Mad" Anthony Wayne, but when a studio executive thought "Anthony" sounded "too Italian," the director suggested "John." John Wayne was not present for this discussion.
In 1928, Walsh was driving on-location as the director of "In Old Arizona," a "Cisco Kid" western that ended up with five Academy Award nominations, including Best Picture, when a jackrabbit leapt through the windshield. In the ensuing crash, Walsh lost his right eye and wore a patch the remainder of his life (pictured below), which abruptly ended his acting sidelight.
Raoul Walsh may have "discovered" and dubbed John Wayne "John Wayne," but the movie star's enduring screen image was forged by a 25-year, 14-picture love-hate relationship under the unrelenting tutelage of director John Ford. Before directing the Duke in what the actor would regard as the best film he ever made, 1956's "The Searchers," John Ford entered a hospital for the routine removal of cataracts. Recuperating from surgery, Ford impatiently unrolled the bandages, inadvertently suffering the loss of sight in his left eye, forcing his use of a patch.
![]() |
| It's ballsy saloon marm Vienna (Joan Crawford) vs. butch vigilante Emma Small (Mercedes McCambridge) in "Johnny Guitar." |
In the late 1960s, Ray often donned a black patch over his right eye (pictured below). Its appearance was random, apparently without any medical causation, and he stopped wearing it altogether during his final years. Patrick McGilligan, the author of a 2011 biography of the director, speculated that Ray believed the patch communicated his credentials as "an adventurer, an outlaw, a buccaneer...who cut a romantic, bigger-than-life figure." Ray, according to McGilligan, brandished the eyepatch like "a crucifixion on his face."
As a venerated cartoonist and director during Hollywood's golden age of animation, Tex Avery created Daffy Duck for Warner Bros. and Droopy for MGM. He lost sight in his left eye while goofing around playing a game he jokingly recalled as "catch-the-paper clip." At Universal Studios, while working for Walter Lantz (the creator of Woody Woodpecker), Tex engaged in office horseplay that resulted in a rubber band-launched paper clip (some say it was a thumbtack) hitting his eye and immediately blinding it.
Some believe that Avery's subsequent loss of depth perception gave his directing a unique, bizarre style, hallmarked by skewed perspectives and exaggerated expressions, illustrated above in Avery's 1945 MGM cartoon "Swing Shift Cinderella."
Whenever veteran character Jack Elam and his distinguishing lazy left eye would pop up on a TV western, our dad would refer to him as "Cockeye." Elam's background was in finance, and he was employed variously as a bookkeeper, auditor, and accountant before his distinctive appearance - the result of a childhood mishap when he was accidentally poked in the eye with a pencil at a Boy Scout meeting - launched a surprising career as one of Hollywood's most unforgettable menaces (pictured below), a malevolent presence he would lampoon onscreen as advancing age turned his features into a human caricature.
Before he was inducted into the fabled Rad Pack, quintessentially tireless entertainer Sammy Davis Jr. knocked on heaven's door in a 1954 car accident on the storied Route 66, losing his left eye on impact with his Cadillac's bullet-shaped horn button. After wearing an eyepatch for six months, he was fitted for a glass eye.
![]() |
| Sammy's friends, actors Tony Curtis and Jeff Chandler, joke around with the entertainer. Following the accident, Chandler volunteered to give one of his eyes if it would keep Davis from total blindness. |
In 1953, Andre DeToth was chosen to direct the cult classic "House of Wax," featuring Vincent Price at his demented best as a disfigured sculptor who rebuilds his destroyed wax museum and repopulates it with wax-covered bodies of his murder victims. "House of Wax" was the first color 3-D motion picture released by a major studio. The curious thing is that DeToth lost sight in one eye at an early age and had no depth perception, so he couldn't appreciate the 3-D effects.
![]() |
| In a gag publicity photo for "House of Wax," the mono-sighted Andre DeToth poses in 3-D glasses with the film's stars, Vincent Price and Phyllis Kirk. |































































































2 comments:
In a holiday mood, I just have to mention what is said to Ralphie numerous times in 1983's "A Christmas Story." "You'll shoot your eye out." It didn't happen in that movie.
But in 1974's "Chinatown," [SPOILER ALERT] it happened to Faye Dunaway in a particularly gruesome way.
One more. In the "Twilight Zone" television series, a 1961 episode, "Will The Real Martian Please Stand Up," featured a Martian with [SPOILER ALERT] a third eye in the middle of his forehead.
A-hem.
Anyway -- great, comprehensive blog post. As usual. Gee whiz, there are a lot of eye patches in popular culture!
Gotta say I do not agree with Roger Ebert on 2004's "Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow." Except for okay production design, the movie was a limp fish. And I like Jude Law and Gwyneth Paltrow. I will say, though, that Angelina Jolie was great in it. I would have enjoyed a movie just featuring her character. When she shouted, "Alert the amphibious squadron!" my heart skipped a beat.
I sorta expected you to go into blind characters, but that may be for another night in the moviehouse. "Zatoichi, The Blind Swordsman" is a pretty great 1960s series of Japanese action movies featuring a, er, blind swordsman. Hey, they worked for me. And there was a recent revival of it in 2003.
And a spiritual successor to Zatoichi is played by Donnie Yen and can be seen (seen!) in theaters now in the new Star Wars spin-off, "Rogue One."
In a non-movie note, the late music hero, Prince, took to wearing an eyepatch for a while. Not sure why. Also not sure why he took to wearing three-lens sunglasses, or having himself represented as having a third eye from time to time. He had a band named 3rd Eye Girl, so maybe that had something to do with it.
One more eye-related person to mention: Peter Falk.
Post a Comment